Ready to build your own Founder-Led Growth engine? Book a Strategy Call
Frontlines.io | Where B2B Founders Talk GTM.
Strategic Communications Advisory For Visionary Founders
Actionable
Takeaways
Supply depth before demand scale prevents unit economics collapse:
Ian's experience across three labor marketplaces reinforced one principle: excess supply is recoverable, excess demand is catastrophic. With too much demand and insufficient supply, you're "spending a bunch of money to acquire these demand users, but you're not able to fulfill the supply side. So now they're churning out at a high clip, they're going somewhere else. And now it drives up your CAC across the marketplace and reduces your lifetime value." In two-sided marketplaces, founders must resist investor pressure to show demand-side revenue before supply reliability is proven—the temporary revenue bump destroys long-term unit economics.
ICP clarity requires live market data, not pre-launch assumptions:
Toothio launched targeting private practices (shorter sales cycles, lower barriers, faster learning) before discovering DSOs were the actual ICP through usage cohorts showing materially higher volume and retention. Ian was explicit: "Once we got into it, we realized...the true ICP is going to be our group practices." The tactical framework: establish presence across plausible segments, instrument everything, collect 1-2 quarters of behavioral data, then redirect resources to wherever retention and expansion metrics are strongest. This data-driven ICP discovery prevents premature optimization around the wrong customer profile.
Hire senior enterprise operators when you have validation plus clear TAM:
Toothio broke conventional early-stage wisdom by hiring a Chief Commercial Officer and SVP Sales—roles typically considered "top-heavy"—because Ian had validated product-market fit and identified a concentrated enterprise opportunity (hundreds of DSOs). The result: "Next thing you know, we're in front of five or six of the top eight or ten DSOs in the country." The decision framework: if you have (1) proven unit economics, (2) clear product-market fit signals, and (3) an enterprise TAM with established relationship networks, senior hires with category Rolodexs can compress multi-year enterprise sales cycles into quarters. Without all three conditions, follow conventional wisdom and stay lean.
Outsider economic analysis creates differentiated value propositions:
Ian's non-dental background enabled him to "look at the dental office P&L and the core drivers of production with a completely neutral lens and realize that there was a lot of waste." He quantified what insiders hadn't: recruiting costs up 100%+ in five years, dental turnover among the highest of any U.S. industry, and the compounding cost of cancelled patient days (immediate production loss + 20% patient churn × $10-15K lifetime values). This economic framing repositioned Toothio from "staffing vendor" to strategic finance partner. The pattern: outsiders should weaponize their fresh perspective by conducting rigorous economic impact analysis that category incumbents haven't done, then speak to buyers in CFO language rather than operational features.
Industry association involvement is enterprise distribution, not brand marketing:
Ian credited local and national dental association sponsorships as "the catalyst to get us on the radar of some of the bigger orgs early" because associations created credibility signals plus network effects at scale. In relationship-driven B2B categories with strong professional associations (dental, legal, accounting, healthcare), sponsorship generates repeated exposure to concentrated decision-maker populations and warm introduction paths that cold outbound can't replicate. Founders should map the association landscape in year one, treat it as a primary distribution channel with measurable pipeline contribution, and staff it with team members who can build genuine relationships—not just write checks.
Conversation
Highlights
How Toothio Built Marketplace Economics by Breaking Conventional Startup Rules
Ian Prendergast had built labor marketplaces before. At Qwick, he launched 15 hospitality staffing markets. At Steady Install, he scaled light industrial contractor placement to five cities in 2020. When a dentist mentioned a staffing crisis during a 2021 golf round, Ian saw pattern recognition, not opportunity.
Then he researched the numbers.
97% of dentists reported staffing as their primary volume constraint. 95% cited extreme recruiting difficulty. Meanwhile, 75% of hygienists prioritized schedule flexibility above everything else—practice type, patient demographics, clinical work didn’t matter.
The structural mismatch was severe. Dental services were growing at 10.5% annually while 40% of the workforce had departed in 2020. In a recent episode of Category Visionaries, Ian, now Co-Founder and CEO of Toothio, shared how marketplace fundamentals from other verticals translated into dental—and where conventional startup wisdom proved catastrophically wrong.
Why Supply-First Prevents Unit Economics Collapse
Most marketplace founders chase paying customers first. Revenue signals traction. Investors want to see demand validation. The pressure to show top-line growth is intense.
Ian inverted the sequence entirely.
“We started recruiting,” he explains. “We would be advertising on various job boards. We would get involved in local and regional groups like hygiene groups, assisting groups, office management clubs.” Months of supply-side development preceded the first practice customer.
The logic emerged from painful experience across three marketplaces: “If you have a ton of demand, not enough supply, well, all of a sudden you’re spending a bunch of money to acquire these demand users, but you’re not able to fulfill the supply side. So now they’re churning out at a high clip, they’re going somewhere else. And now it drives up your CAC across the marketplace and reduces your lifetime value.”
Excess supply is recoverable—you can throttle recruitment spending and let utilization catch up. Excess demand destroys the business model. You’re burning capital to acquire customers who immediately churn because you can’t deliver the core promise. CAC spikes while LTV collapses.
The principle extends beyond marketplaces. In any business where reliability drives retention, proving you can deliver consistently matters more than proving someone will pay. Quality and reliability were Toothio’s only defensible product, and both required supply depth before demand scale.
How Usage Data Reveals Your Actual ICP
Toothio launched targeting private dental practices. The thesis made sense: shorter sales cycles, lower risk, faster iteration cycles. Classic bottoms-up validation.
After collecting behavioral data across segments, a different picture emerged. “We realized, okay, there certainly is a need on the private practice side of this market,” Ian says. “But the true ICP is going to be our group practices.”
DSOs—dental service organizations ranging from small groups to enterprise roll-ups like MB2 and Heartland—showed fundamentally different usage patterns. Higher booking volume. Stickier retention. More strategic about how they deployed flexible staffing to manage seasonality and turnover.
The tactical framework Ian used: establish presence across plausible segments, instrument everything, collect 1-2 quarters of cohort data, then redirect resources toward wherever retention and expansion metrics are strongest.
Private practices weren’t a mistake—they served a specific purpose. Lower barriers to entry meant faster market education. Shorter sales cycles meant rapid feedback on product-market fit. They were the right customers for validation, just not the right customers for scale.
This sequencing matters. Premature enterprise focus without product validation burns time in long sales cycles before you know if the product works. But staying in SMB too long after data shows enterprise fit caps growth potential.
When Senior Hires Compress Enterprise Cycles
With DSO validation established, Ian made a decision that typically triggers investor pushback: he hired a Chief Commercial Officer and Senior VP of Sales.
“Historically, early stage is not exactly a great thing,” he acknowledges. “Investors try to shine you away from that. Like, hey, we don’t want a top heavy org. You want a bunch of ICs. You want to be doing a lot of still founder led sales.”
The result validated the bet. “All of a sudden we brought in a couple big wigs in the dental space. They started making introductions. Next thing you know, we’re in front of five or six of the top eight or ten DSOs in the country.”
The decision framework was specific: validated product-market fit, clear unit economics, and a concentrated enterprise TAM where relationship networks created asymmetric advantages. Without all three conditions, conventional wisdom holds—stay lean, keep founder-led sales, hire ICs.
But when those conditions exist, senior operators with category Rolodexs can compress multi-year relationship-building into quarters. The top 10 DSOs weren’t discoverable through cold outbound. They required warm introductions from operators who had sold into them before and understood their procurement processes.
How Outsider Analysis Creates Differentiated Positioning
Not being from dental created an obvious credibility problem. Ian solved it systematically: “I knew I was smart enough to know that I didn’t know. So the pieces that we needed to put around us were people that were SMEs, people that understood the space even down to people that ran our orientations.”
Toothio hired hygienists to conduct orientation sessions. They brought in advisors who had sold into DSOs. They embedded dental professionals across operations to build category expertise.
But the outsider lens also unlocked something insiders had completely missed.
“I was able to come in and look at the dental office P&L and the core drivers of production with a completely neutral lens and realize that there was a lot of waste,” Ian explains. He conducted the economic analysis the industry hadn’t done: recruiting costs had increased over 100% in five years. Dental turnover ranked among the highest of any U.S. industry—higher than retail, approaching hospitality levels.
Then he quantified the compounding cost of unstaffed days. Each unstaffed hygienist day cost $1,560 in lost production. But the second-order effect was worse: “You’re going to lose two out of those 10 patients that you’re going to see that day. They’re going to go somewhere else with their lifetime values are $10 to $15,000.”
The math: $1,560 immediate production loss + (20% patient churn × $12,500 average LTV) = $4,060 total cost per unstaffed day. Multiply across seasonality, sick days, and turnover cycles, and the annual impact for a single hygienist position approached $50,000+.
“We were able to work backwards and create this very tangible ROI,” Ian says. “That then allowed us to come back to our customers and establish ourselves as subject matter experts and speak their language.”
This economic framing repositioned Toothio from staffing vendor to strategic finance partner speaking CFO language. It’s the kind of analysis that requires distance from industry orthodoxy—insiders were too close to the problem to see the full P&L impact.
Why Associations Function as Enterprise Distribution
In relationship-driven B2B categories, finding concentrated access to decision-makers without burning budget on low-conversion outbound is challenging. Ian found it through industry associations.
“Getting involved in local and national associations was a big deal from a credibility factor for us,” he explains. “Once we sponsored a few events and we sponsored a few association events and we got our name out there, I think that was kind of the catalyst to get us on the radar of some of the bigger orgs early.”
Associations work because they create repeated exposure in trusted contexts. When DSO executives see Toothio sponsoring the regional dental conference, speaking on workforce panels, and actively participating in industry conversations, it generates credibility that cold emails can’t replicate.
The network effects compound. Association involvement led to conversations with other vendors who made introductions to shared customers. It positioned Toothio as category participants, not just vendors selling into the category.
For B2B founders in industries with strong professional associations—legal, accounting, healthcare, financial services—this represents primary distribution infrastructure. The playbook: map the association landscape early, treat sponsorship as pipeline investment with measurable contribution, and staff it with team members building genuine relationships.
Building Moats Over Distribution Channels
Ian sees the labor marketplace as foundation, not destination. “I think labor marketplace in general is fantastic, especially right now because you’re building a distribution channel and you’re building usually a hyper engaged distribution channel that is not going to be automated out with AI.”
The next phase: layering SaaS over the distribution channel to increase switching costs. “It’s about layering software over the top. What kind of additional value? Looking at the RCM, revenue cycle management, looking at other softwares that are being used in the practice and then how can we consolidate that into one clean, easy to use platform and add business value and ultimately build our moat.”
The pattern is familiar—Toast with restaurant POS, Shopify with e-commerce infrastructure, Procore with construction management. Build distribution through a high-frequency transaction product, then expand into adjacent software that benefits from the data and relationships the core business generates.
Toothio’s national expansion is already underway, using AI agents to eliminate the geographic constraints that traditionally limit labor marketplaces. For an industry where 97% of practices cite staffing as their primary growth limiter, the TAM remains structural and massive.
The bigger lesson isn’t about dental staffing. It’s about when to break conventional startup wisdom. Supply before demand prevented unit economics collapse. Data-driven ICP discovery avoided premature optimization. Senior enterprise hires compressed sales cycles when conditions warranted. Outsider economic analysis created differentiated positioning.
Sometimes the best move is ignoring the playbook entirely.
Recommended Founder
Interviews
Brett Kleger
CEO of Datacubed Health
Brett Kleger, CEO of Datacubed Health: $43 Million Raised to Revolutionize Clinical Trial Data Collection
Todd Zion
Founder of Akston Biosciences
Todd Zion, Founder of Akston Biosciences: From a $500M Exit to Pioneering Biotech Innovation in Pet Health
Kourosh Davarpanah
Co-Founder and CEO of Inato
Kourosh Davarpanah, Co-Founder and CEO of Inato: Over $35 Million Raised to Build the Future of Clinical Trials
Kyle Kiser
CEO of Arrive Health
Kyle Kiser, CEO of Arrive Health: Over $40 Million Raised to Improve the Value of Healthcare Through Informed Decision-Making
Brock Leonti
CEO & Co-Founder of Prescribe FIT
Brock Leonti, CEO & Co-Founder of Prescribe FIT: $15 Million Raised to Build the Future of Orthopedic Care
Michael Chang
Mastering Market Fit in AI: Insights from Michael Chang, Director of Marketing at ArteraAI
Thomas Knox
CEO & Founder of VitVio
Thomas Knox, CEO & Founder of VitVio: $10 Million Raised to Transform Surgical Operations Through AI-Powered Automation
Nabeel Kaukab
Founder and CEO of Phamily
How Phamily built an eight-figure ARR healthcare company without discounting: The subsidized R&D approach | Nabeel Kaukab ($25M Raised)
Cesar Herrera
CEO and Co-Founder of Yuvo Health
Cesar Herrera, CEO and Co-Founder of Yuvo Health: $28 Million Raised to Revolutionize Healthcare Access
Dipanwita Das
CEO and Co-Founder of Sorcero
Dipanwita Das, CEO and Co-Founder of Sorcero: Over $20 Million Raised to Power Medical Affairs Teams of the Future
Joe Gagnon
CEO of 1upHealth
Joe Gagnon, CEO at 1upHealth: Over $75 Million Raised to Build the Future of Healthcare Data
Mike Desjadon
CEO of Anomaly
Why Anomaly avoids annual curiosity revenue (ACR) — and you probably should to | Mike Desjadon ($30M Raised)
Derek Streat
Co-Founder & Chief Executive Officer of Dexcare
Derek Streat, CEO of Dexcare: $110 Million Raised to Help Health Systems to Find Time for the Best Care
Mark Lehmkuhle
CEO & Founder of Epitel
Mark Lehmkuhle, CEO & Founder of Epitel: $20 Million Raised to Build the Future of Brain Health Monitoring
Kevin Flyangolts
CEO and Founder of Aclid
Kevin Flyangolts, CEO & Founder of Aclid: $4 Million Raised to Build the Future of Biosecurity
Kristen Valdes
CEO & Founder of B.well
Kristen Valdes, CEO & Founder of B.well: $100 Million Raised to Reimagine the Healthcare Experience
David King Lassman
Founder of GigXR
David King Lassman, Founder of GigXR: $7 Million Raised to Bring Immersive Learning to Healthcare
Viral Patel
Founder and CEO of Radish Health
Viral Patel, CEO of Radish Health: $5 Million Raised to Connect Employees with a Better Healthcare Experience
Armon Sharei
CEO & Founder of Portal
Armon Sharei, CEO & Founder of Portal: $5 Million Raised to Power the Future of Cell Engineering
Teodor Grantcharov
Founder of Surgical Safety Technologies Inc.
How Surgical Safety Technologies targeted the most challenging customers first (massive hospitals) | Teodor Grantcharov
Rafid Fadul
CEO and Co-Founder of Zivian Health
Rafid Fadul, CEO and Co-Founder of Zivian Health: $3 Million Raised to Power the Future of Compliant Healthcare Collaborations
Cody Simmons
CEO of DermaSensor
Cody Simmons, CEO of DermaSensor: $36 Million Raised to Build the First AI-Powered Skin Cancer Detection Tool for Primary Care
Rishi Nayyar
CEO and Co-Founder of PocketHealth
Rishi Nayyar, CEO and Co-Founder of PocketHealth: $22.5 Million Raised to Power the Future of Medical Image Sharing
Daniel West
CEO of Prospection
Daniel West, CEO of Prospection: $36 Million Raised to Build the Future of Patient-Centric Intelligence
James Bates
CEO and Founder of AdviNOW Medical
James Bates, CEO and Founder of AdviNOW Medical: $24 Million Raised to Build the Future of AI-Powered Healthcare
Samson Magid
Co-Founder and CEO of HealthSnap
Samson Magid, Co-Founder and CEO of HealthSnap: Over $12 Million Raised to Build the Future of Remote Patient Monitoring
Matthew Stoudt
CEO and Founder of AppliedVR
Matthew Stoudt, CEO and Founder of AppliedVR: Over $70 Million Raised to Build the Future of Chronic Pain Relief
Veer Gidwaney
CEO & Founder of Ansel Health
Veer Gidwaney, CEO & Founder of Ansel Health: $50 Million Raised to Transform Supplemental Health Insurance
Itzik Cohen
Co-Founder and CEO of PayZen
Itzik Cohen, Co-Founder and CEO of PayZen: $240 Million Raised to Build the Future of Affordable Health Care
Elad Ferber
CEO & Co-Founder of Synthpop
Elad Ferber, CEO & Co-Founder of Synthpop: $8 Million Raised to Build the Future of Healthcare Administration with AI
Hala Borno
Founder and CEO of Trial Library
Hala Borno, Founder and CEO of Trial Library: $5M Raised to Improve Patient Recruitment and Diversity in Oncology Clinical Trials
Marshall Darr
CEO & Co-Founder of StretchDollar
How StretchDollar drives leads from LLM search | Marshall Darr
Torben Nielsen
CEO & Co-Founder of Uptiv Health
Torben Nielsen, CEO of Uptiv Health: $7.5M Raised to Build the Future of Infusion Therapy Through Technology-Enabled Retail Centers
Joseph Schneier
CEO of Trusty Care
Joseph Schneier, CEO of Trusty Care: $13+ Million Raised to Shape the Future of Medicare
Brandon Young
CMO of Garner Health
Why Marketing Lost Its Craft (And How AI Could Force It Back)
Henry O’Connell
CEO & Founder of Canary Speech
Henry O’Connell, CEO & Founder of Canary Speech: $26 Million Raised to Build the Future of Vocal Biomarker Technology
Jocelyn Nowak
Marketing & Sales Enablement Lead of FIGUR8
Integrity-Driven Marketing: FIGUR8’s Path to 3,000+ Clinics
Daniel Lambert
CEO of PathologyWatch
Daniel Lambert, CEO of PathologyWatch: Over $50 Million Raised to Build the Future of Digital Pathology
Michael Gorton
Founder of Teladoc
Teladoc Founder Michael Gorton on the Early Days of Pioneering the Telemedicine Category (And What’s He’s Up to Next)
Nick Soman
CEO & Founder of Decent
Nick Soman, CEO & Founder of Decent: $43 Million Raised to Build the Future of Direct Primary Care
Gregory Stein
CEO of Shadowbox
How Shadowbox evolved it’s ICP from desperate labs to health systems with 500-1,000 community providers | Gregory Stein
Trenor Williams
CEO and Co-Founder of Socially Determined
Trenor Williams, CEO and Co-Founder of Socially Determined: $34 Million Raised to Build the Social Risk Intelligence Category
Matt Renfro
Co-Founder & CEO of Lynx
Matt Renfro, CEO of Lynx: $17.5 Million raised to Bring Modern Fintech to Healthcare
Vicky Demas
CEO of Identifeye Health
Vicky Demas, CEO of identifeye HEALTH: $90 Million Raised to Power the Future of Retinal Imaging
Danny Freed
CEO & Founder of Blueprint
Danny Freed, CEO & Founder of Blueprint: $13.7 Million Raised to Build the Future of Therapist Enablement
Khaled Boukadoum
Founder of Torch Dental
Khaled Boukadoum, Founder of Torch Dental: $49.5 Million Raised to Transform Dental Supply Management Through Digital Innovation
Stacy Edgar
CEO and Co-Founder of Venteur
Stacy Edgar, CEO & Co-Founder of Venteur: $7.6 Million Raised to Build the Future of Health Insurance
Aasim Saeed
CEO and Founder of Amenities Health
Aasim Saeed, CEO and Founder of Amenities Health: $10 Million Raised to Build the Future of Patient Engagement
Dimitrios Skaltsas
CEO & Co-Founder of Intelligencia AI
Dimitrios Skaltsas, CEO & Co-Founder of Intelligencia AI: $15.5 Million Raised to Build the Future of Drug Development
Austin McChord
CEO of Casana
Austin McChord, CEO of Casana: Over $46 Million Raised to Create the Future of In-Home Health Monitoring
David Berry
CEO and Founder of Valo
David Berry, CEO and Founder of Valo: Over $500 Million Raised to Build the Future of Drug Discovery
Corey Washington
Senior Marketing Manager of Amenities Health
Humanizing Healthcare Tech: Marketing Lessons from Amenities
Verena Gerhardus
Director of Growth of Nelly Solutions
How Nelly Grew 3X Through Meta Ads in Health Tech
Alfred Griffin
CEO and Co-Founder of CEO and Co-Founder
Alfred Griffin, CEO and Co-Founder of LightForce: $150 Million Raised to Power the Future of Orthodontics
Andreas Cleve
CEO and Co-Founder of Corti
Andreas Cleve, CEO and Co-Founder of Corti: $32 Million Raised to Power the Future of Patient Consultations
Richard Queen
CEO and Co-Founder of DignifiHealth
Richard Queen, CEO and Co-Founder of DignifiHealth: $7 Million Raised to Drive Better Patient Outcomes in Rural Healthcare and Beyond
Alexandra Ferraro
Head of Marketing of Intelligencia AI
Beyond Perfect: Healthcare Tech Marketing That Drives Real Revenue
Ignacio Medrano
Founder & CMO of Savana
Ignacio Medrano, Founder & CMO of Savana: $44M Raised to Transform Healthcare Intelligence Through AI
Justin Dearborn
Founder & CEO of Praia Health
Justin Dearborn, Founder & CEO of Praia Health: $20 Million Raised to Build the Future of Consumer Experience in Healthcare
Jennifer Bittinger
President and Founder of Narrativa
How Narrativa leveraged COVID-19 as a market catalyst to accelerate AI adoption in pharma | Jennifer Bittinger ($2.4M Raised)
Michael Passanante
Senior Vice President of Marketing and Communications of Capital Rx
How to Build 18-Month Attribution Models That Actually Work
Senan Ebrahim
CEO & Founder of Delfina
Senan Ebrahim, CEO & Founder of Delfina: $10 Million Raised to Build the Future of Intelligent Pregnancy Care
Dr. Nan-Wei Gong
CEO and Founder of FIGUR8
Dr. Nan-Wei Gong, CEO & Founder of FIGUR8: $40 Million Raised to Build the Future of Musculoskeletal Health and Injury Data Solutions
Dr Thomas Oakley
CEO of Feedback PLC
Dr Thomas Oakley, CEO of Feedback PLC: £20 Million Raised to Build the Future of Patient Data Sharing
Trey Sutten
CEO & Co-Founder of Siftwell Analytics
Trey Sutten, CEO & Co-Founder of Siftwell Analytics: $5 Million Raised to Transform Healthcare Analytics with AI-Powered Predictions
Joshua Miller
CEO and Co-Founder of Gradient Health
Joshua Miller, CEO & Co-Founder of Gradient Health: $5.7 Million Raised to Build the Future of Medical Imaging
Amar Kendale
President and Co-Founder of Homeward
Amar Kendale, President & Co-Founder of Homeward: $70 Million Raised to Transform Rural Healthcare Through Technology
Rebecca McNeil
VP of Marketing of SureCost
Why This VP of Marketing Abandoned Paid Media Completely
Alex Zekoff
CEO and Co-Founder of Thoughtful AI
Alex Zekoff, CEO and Co-Founder of Thoughtful AI: $21 Million Raised to Power the Future of Healthcare Automation
Ben Albert
CEO & Co-Founder of Upfront Healthcare
Ben Albert, CEO & Co-Founder of Upfront Healthcare: $30 Million Raised to Power the Future of Patient Engagement
Amy Brown
CEO and Founder of Authenticx
Amy Brown, CEO and Founder of Authenticx: $28 Million Raised to Build the Future of Listening AI
Brad Kittredge
CEO & Co-Founder of Brightside
Brad Kittredge, CEO & Co-Founder of Brightside: $150 Million Raised to Build the Future of Mental Healthcare
Omer Maman
VP of Marketing of Healthee
Why AI Should Enhance, Not Replace Your Marketing Team
Dilpreet Sahota
CEO of Trek Health
Dilpreet Sahota, CEO of Trek Health: $3 Million Raised to Help Mental Health Providers Accept Insurance
Ty Allen
CEO of SocialClimb
Ty Allen, CEO of SocialClimb: $12 Million Raised to Power the Future of Healthcare Marketing