Listen Here

| |

Conversation
Highlights

 

Sometimes the best way to grow is to shrink first. In a recent episode of Category Visionaries, Matt Bivons, CEO and Founder of Canopy, shared how cutting 50% of their sales pipeline led to “massive growth” in 2024. But this wasn’t the first time radical focus reshaped Canopy’s trajectory.

 

The Failed Credit Card Dream

Five years ago, Matt had a vision: build a safe credit card for students. Armed with his background in design and marketing, he hit Sand Hill Road. The response? Universal rejection, including from Y Combinator.

“I screamed into a pillow that night,” Matt recalls. But the next morning, a friend offered brutal advice: “You’re an amazing founder, but this hill that you’re trying to climb is just too much.”

Instead of doubling down, Matt did something counterintuitive. He reached out to major fintech companies like Chime and Greenlight, asking if they needed lending infrastructure. “Every single one said yes,” Matt explains. That market signal sparked a complete pivot.

 

The Infrastructure Insight

Matt stripped away everything related to the student credit card, focusing solely on what he calls “the hardest thing about what we were building, that no one else has that everybody else wants” – the loan servicing infrastructure.

This focus on infrastructure wasn’t just a tactical choice. It reflected a deeper insight about the lending industry. “90% of the lifecycle of a loan happens in the servicing layer,” Matt notes. Yet existing systems were rigid, causing problems in both product creation and customer service.

 

The Failed Self-Serve Experiment

But finding the right product was only half the battle. Canopy’s initial go-to-market strategy – a self-serve, API-first platform charging per call – proved disastrous.

“It attracted the wrong type of customer,” Matt explains. “We were getting kids from Stanford in their dorms trying us out. And lending is really hard. Like you have to know what you’re doing and that was not our customer.”

The pricing model also failed: “Charging per API call, similar to how Twilio does, is very confusing to most people when you’re dealing with lending because the amount of contacts that you get matters based on the lending product you have.”

 

The B2B Focus

In 2024, Canopy made their boldest move yet: eliminating their entire consumer lending business, which represented over 50% of their sales pipeline. Matt describes it as “a scary one…because you have a bird in hand of companies that want to work with us.”

But this focus enabled something crucial: depth over breadth. “We were just spread way too thin,” Matt reflects, “and we needed to go a lot deeper in the market that we’re being pulled into.”

This depth manifests in Canopy’s sophisticated market segmentation. They analyze opportunities through two dimensions: vertical markets (logistics, healthcare, ecommerce) and horizontal loan types (revolving credit, merchant cash advance). “If the verticals are the business model, the loan type is the horizontal that goes across them,” Matt explains.

 

The Future Vision

Today, Canopy is building what Matt calls “intelligent servicing” – transforming loan servicing from a cost center into a profit center through AI and ML. Their thesis remains unchanged: facilitate best-in-class lending experiences. The path to get there? Completely different than planned.

This journey offers a crucial lesson for B2B founders: sometimes the most powerful growth strategy is knowing what to cut. As Matt puts it, “There’s a fine line for founders of being stubborn on one side and resilient on the other… you also have to know when the universe is telling you something.”

For Canopy, listening to those signals – even when they meant saying no to revenue – has proven to be the key to unlocking their most significant growth yet.

 

Actionable
Takeaways

Embrace market signals for pivots:

Matt initially planned to build a student credit card but pivoted to loan servicing infrastructure after recognizing stronger market demand. He shares, "I realized at that moment that was the market pool, that was the signal that was saying I need to pivot." B2B founders should remain attuned to market feedback and be willing to adapt their vision accordingly.

Find your wedge by going deeper:

When Canopy eliminated 50% of their sales pipeline by cutting consumer lending, it enabled deeper penetration into B2B markets. Matt explains, "We were just spread way too thin, and we needed to go a lot deeper in the market that we're being pulled into." B2B founders should consider strategic trade-offs between market breadth and depth.

Validate distribution assumptions:

Matt learned that self-serve "lending as a service" attracted the wrong customers and complicated pricing. He notes, "It attracted the wrong type of customer... charging per API call is very confusing to most people when you're dealing with lending." B2B founders should thoroughly test go-to-market assumptions before scaling.

Validate distribution assumptions:

Matt learned that self-serve "lending as a service" attracted the wrong customers and complicated pricing. He notes, "It attracted the wrong type of customer... charging per API call is very confusing to most people when you're dealing with lending." B2B founders should thoroughly test go-to-market assumptions before scaling.

Segment your market precisely:

Canopy analyzes their market by both vertical (logistics, healthcare, etc.) and horizontal loan types (revolving credit, merchant cash advance, etc.). Matt explains, "If the verticals are the business model, the loan type is the horizontal that goes across them." B2B founders should develop detailed market segmentation to guide product and GTM strategy.

Recommended Founder
Interviews

Felix Rodriguez

CEO & Founder of Finally

Felix Rodriguez, CEO & Founder of Finally: $110 Million Raised to Power the Future of Finance Automation

Jessica Zhang

CEO & Co-Founder of Pier

Jessica Zhang, CEO & Co-Founder of Pier: $2.5M Raised to Build the Future of Credit Infrastructure

Ankit Ratan

Co-Founder and CEO of Signzy

Ankit Ratan, Co-Founder and CEO of Signzy: Over $38 Million Raised to Build the Future of Digital Onboarding Infrastructure

Bob Suh

CEO of OnCorps

Bob Suh, CEO of OnCorps: $18M Raised to Help Large Financial Institutions Solve Operational Problems with AI

Julio Martínez

Co-Founder and CEO of Abacum

Julio Martínez, Co-Founder and CEO at Abacum: $40 Million Raised to Build the Future of FP&A

Fady Hawatmeh

Founder and CEO of Clockwork

Fady Hawatmeh, Founder and CEO of Clockwork: Nearly $3 Million Raised to Make Financial Modeling and Cash Flow Forecasting Easy

Arik Shtilman

CEO of Rapyd

Arik Shtilman, Rapyd: $15 Billion Valuation (Unicorn Builders)

Don Muir

CEO of Arc

Don Muir, CEO of Arc: Over $180 Million Raised to Empower Startups with a Better Cash Management Experience

Kalpesh Kapadia

CEO and Founder of Deserve

Kalpesh Kapadia, CEO and Founder of Deserve: $50 Million Raised to Build the Future of Credit Cards

Iris Pfeifer

VP of Growth of Wisetack

Iris Pfeifer, VP of Growth at Wisetack: Mastering B2B Marketing Through Sales Alignment and Product Strategy

Ron Benegbi

CEO & Founder of Uplinq

Ron Benegbi, CEO & Founder at Uplinq: Over $5 Million Raised to Transform SMB Lender’s Existing Credit Evaluation Process

Rodney Reisdorf

Co-Founder & CEO of Co-Founder & CEO

Rodney Reisdorf, CEO of Verivend: $3 Million Raised Transform Private Capital Transactions

Brian King

CEO of LODAS Markets

Brian King, CEO of LODAS Markets: $8.5 Million Raised to Power the Future of Alternative Investments

Jack McDonald

CEO of PolySign

Jack McDonald, CEO of PolySign: $50 Million Raised to Power the Future of Digital Assets

Patrick Mollard

CEO & Co-Founder of Fipto

Patrick Mollard, CEO & Co-Founder of Fipto: $16 Million Raised to Build the Future of Blockchain Payments

Wade Arnold

CEO and Founder of Moov

Wade Arnold, CEO and Founder of Moov: $77.5 Million Raised to Build the Future of Embedded Payments

Magali Chapuis

Marketing Manager of Embat

Magali Chapuis, Marketing Manager of Embat: Strategic Insights for Scaling Fintech Marketing Across Borders

Ben Borodach

Co-Founder and CEO of April

Ben Borodach, Co-Founder and CEO of April: $40 Million Raised to Embed Intelligent Tax Experiences

Kevin Hart

Founder and CEO of Green Check Verified

Kevin Hart, Founder and CEO of Green Check Verified: $16 Million Raised to Power the Future of the Cannabis Business

John Lunn

CEO and Founder of Gr4vy

John Lunn, CEO and Founder of Gr4vy: $27 Million Raised to Build the Future of Payments Infrastructure

Swapnil Shinde

CEO and Co-Founder of Zeni

Swapnil Shinde, CEO and Co-Founder of Zeni: $47+ Million Raised to Build the Finance Operations Category

Scott Dorey

Co-Founder of OpenPath

Scott Dorey, Co-Founder of OpenPath: $25 Million Raised to Build the Future of Payments

Daumantas Dvilinskas

CEO & Co-Founder of TransferGo

Daumantas Dvilinskas, CEO & Co-Founder of TransferGo: $125 Million Raised to Build the Future of Cross-Border Payments

Helen Chong

Head of Growth of Puzzle

Helen Chong, Head of Growth at Puzzle: Collaborating with Founders – Insights for Effective Marketing Alignment

Klas Bäck

CEO & Co-Founder of Pagos

Klas Bäck, CEO & Co-Founder of Pagos: $44 Million Raised to Power the Future of Payments Operations

Eric Velasquez Frenkiel

Founder and CEO of Pomelo

Eric Velasquez Frenkiel, CEO of Pomelo: $70 Million Raised to Build the Future of Remittance

Steve Pomfret

Steve Pomfret, CEO & Founder of Cygnetise: $8 Million Raised to Build the Future of Signatory Management

Colin Luce

CEO & Co-Founder of Basis Theory

Colin Luce, CEO & Co-Founder of Basis Theory: $20 Million Raised to Build the Future of Payments Tokenization

Yasmin Graeml

Marketing & Communication Leader of Flourish Fi

Yasmin, Marketing & Communication Leader at Flourish Fi: Driving Financial Engagement with Innovative Tech

Jeremy Almond

CEO & Founder of Paystand

Jeremy Almond, CEO & Founder of Paystand: $100M Raised to Power the Future of B2B Payments

Nik Talreja

CEO & Co-Founder of Sydecar

Nik Talreja, CEO & Co-Founder of Sydecar: Over $16 Million Raised to Make Venture Deal Execution a Frictionless Process

Jonas Overgaard

CEO of Anyday.io

Jonas Overgaard, CEO of Anyday.io: $4M Raised to Transform the Buy Now Pay Later Market

Reed Switzer

CEO of Hopscotch

Reed Switzer, CEO of Hopscotch: $10M to Build the Future of B2B Payments For SMBs

Thibaut Sahagian

CEO of Multis

Thibaut Sahagian, CEO of Multis: $9 Million Raised to Build a New Category of Software Designed to Meet the Needs of Web3 Organizations

Shamir Karkal

Co-founder and CSO of Sila

Shamir Karkal, CEO of Sila: $20+ Million Raised to Build the Money API For Fintech

Stephany Kirkpatrick

CEO and Founder of Orum

Stephany Kirkpatrick, CEO and Founder of Orum: Over $85 Million Raised to Build an API integration for Instant Payouts

Dan Beck

Dan Beck, CEO & Co-Founder of 401GO: $14 Million Raised to Build the Future of Retirement Benefits for Small Businesses

Rafael Loureiro

CEO of Wealth

Rafael Loureiro, CEO of Wealth: $16 Million Raised to Build the Future of Estate Planning

Daniel Grunstein

CEO and Co-Founder of Crowded

Daniel Grunstein, CEO and Co-Founder of Crowded: $6.4 Million Raised to Transform Nonprofit Financial Management

Sohaib Zahid

CEO and Co-Founder of Railz

Sohaib Zahid, CEO and Co-Founder of Railz: $15 Million Raised to Build to Accounting Data as a Service Category

Brendan Playford

CEO of Pngme

Brendan Playford, CEO of Pngme: $18 Million Raised to Support Financial Inclusivity and Unlock Economic Potential Across the Developing World

Olga Chin

CEO and Founder of InterPrice Technologies

Olga Chin, CEO and Founder of InterPrice Technologies: Over $10 Million Raised to Build the Future of Capital Markets Treasury Management

Ben Goldin

CEO and Founder of Plumery

Ben Goldin, CEO and Founder of Plumery: $4.5 Million Raised to Power the Future of Digital Engagement for Banks

Steven Greene

CEO of Standard Practice

Steven Greene, CEO & Co-Founder of Standard Practice (Previously Nibble Health): $8 Million Raised to Bring the Fintech Revolution to the World Healthcare Payments

Florian Wimmer

Co-Founder & CEO of Blockpit

Florian Wimmer, Co-Founder & CEO of Blockpit: $15 Million Raised to Power the Future of Crypto Tax Management

Ahmad Ibrahim

CEO of NeoTax

Ibrahim, CEO of NeoTax: $13 Million Raised to Build the Future of Tax Automation

Laura Kornhauser

Co-Founder and CEO of Stratyfy

Laura Kornhauser, Co-Founder and CEO at Stratyfy: $10 Million Raised to Power the Future of Financial Inclusion